A checklist for choosing an email platform fits on one sheet of paper: six lines, each one a question you can answer during a free trial. Most of the answers sit on screens a sales page never shows, such as the automation library, the form settings and the domain setup page, so the list only works if you open a trial account and click through them yourself. Moving a list, its sign-up forms and its automations to another platform later means rebuilding each flow and form by hand, which is why the checking happens before the first email goes out.
Two well-known platforms set side by side make a good worked example before you run the checks on your own shortlist. A klaviyo vs mailchimp comparison runs the six checks below on both, so you can see what each check turns up before you open your own trial accounts.
Count the contacts you can actually email
Bring one number to any sign-up: the contacts you can actually email today. Export your customer list from the store admin and count the rows that have an email address and a marketing consent flag set to yes. If someone bought once and never opted in, leave them off the list.

Photo: Jakub Żerdzicki / Unsplash
Then clean that count. Merge duplicates, such as a shopper who signed up twice with the same address, and drop the addresses that bounced or unsubscribed on earlier sends. Email tools charge by list size, so compare prices at this cleaned number, with a glance at the next tier up for the growth you expect this year.
Try the automations and the editor during the trial
Start with the emails that should go out without anyone pressing send. For a small shop that’s three: the welcome email when someone joins the list, the reminder when a shopper leaves a full cart, and the thank-you email after a first order with a note about care, sizing or how to reorder. Order confirmations and shipping updates come from your store platform itself, so the email tool doesn’t need to handle those in the first week.
During the free trial, open the automation library and find each of the three as a ready-made flow. A usable one lets you switch it on, change the wording, and set the delay between messages, an hour or a day, from a dropdown. If the cart reminder only works after a developer has set up a custom event, count that against the platform, because the reminder needs to run from the first week and that setup has to be done by someone who writes code.
Look at the editor as well. Drag in your logo, a product photo and a button, then preview the email on your phone. Note how long that first email takes, and plan the same time for each newsletter you send.

Photo: Jakub Żerdzicki / Unsplash
Check how it connects to your store
Find your store platform by name on the integrations page, then read what the connection syncs: customers, orders, products and cart activity. The cart reminder from the previous check depends on that last one. Check that an integration you install from your store’s app marketplace syncs all four. A connection built through a third-party bridge such as Zapier passes only what someone set it up to pass, runs on a separate account with its own plan, and is one more place where a new customer’s email address stops syncing without anyone noticing.
Sign-up forms and the consent behind them
Your list grows through forms: the pop-up on the homepage, the box in the footer, the checkbox at checkout. Build the pop-up you’d actually use during the trial and check three things. The consent checkbox has to start unchecked. The platform has to be able to send a confirmation email that the new subscriber clicks before they’re added, which is called double opt-in. And each contact record has to store when and where that person signed up.
The large mailbox providers ask for the same habits. Yahoo’s sender requirements and recommendations tell senders not to pre-tick opt-in boxes, to confirm new subscriptions by email, and to tell people at sign-up what they’ll receive and how often. The same page asks bulk senders to process unsubscribe requests within two days, which the platform should do automatically from the link in every email footer. If you sell to customers in the UK or the EU, data protection law also expects you to be able to show when and how each person agreed, and the sign-up record is where that proof lives.
Open the form settings and look for a line of text under the email field. That’s where you tell people what they’re signing up for, such as one email a week with new stock and the occasional discount code.
Costs that sit outside the headline price
With a clean contact count, a list of automations and a store integration you’ve checked, the price check gets shorter. If a cheap plan fails one of the earlier checks, you pay for a workaround instead, such as a separate form tool or a connector app. This blog has already looked at the hidden costs in email marketing pricing, so here the check is narrower. Look at whether the free plan adds the platform’s logo to your emails, whether there’s a monthly sending cap on top of the contact limit, whether SMS is billed as separate credits, and how much the annual plan saves against paying month by month. The comparison above shows two platforms’ prices pulling apart tier by tier, so check each one on your shortlist at your 12-month figure as well as today’s.
Set up sending before the first campaign
Mailbox providers want proof that an email claiming to come from your shop really does, and that proof sits in a few short text records added to your domain’s DNS settings. SPF lists the servers allowed to send mail for your domain. DKIM adds a signature to each message. DMARC tells the receiving server what to do when a message fails those checks, and it sends you reports about it.
Pick a platform that walks you through this. Its setup screen should show the exact records to paste into your domain registrar, then a status next to each one that turns green once it’s found them. If you haven’t logged into your domain registrar since the day you bought the domain, budget an evening to find the DNS page and paste in three odd-looking lines. With the records and a short guide on screen, you can finish the job in one sitting.
The minimum comes from the mailbox providers themselves. Under Google’s requirements for anyone sending to Gmail, every sender needs SPF or DKIM in place and has to keep the share of messages people mark as spam under 0.3 percent. Once a sender passes 5,000 messages a day to Gmail addresses, SPF and DKIM are both required, along with DMARC and one-click unsubscribe. Add all three records now and you won’t have to touch DNS again when your list grows. Send from an address on your shop’s own domain rather than a free webmail address.
Once the records show green, send a test email from the trial account to a Gmail address, open it, choose “Show original” from the three-dot menu, and check that SPF, DKIM and DMARC each read PASS.